
Another lawsuit suggests Apple and Google are conspirators
A lawsuit alleges that a conspiratorial deal made between Apple and Google in 2005 locked competitive search engines out of the market, and a judge has inexplicably chosen to let it move to trial.
There are a lot of reasons to look at Apple and Google’s relationship from a regulatory lens, but a new class action lawsuit in Canada takes a very peculiar angle. It isn’t the first time Apple and Google’s relationship has been brought into question, but the new class action lawsuit focuses on Apple.
According to a filing in British Columbia first shared by 9to5Mac, a judge has chosen to allow a class action lawsuit against Apple to move forward to trial. It originally involved Google, but Google Search Ads has an arbitration clause that had to be honored.
The plaintiff was told to pursue Google through that arbitration clause, but never did. Instead, the lawsuit was modified to focus on Apple’s alleged conspiracy to ensure Google would become the global search giant that controls the market.
The thrust of the lawsuit suggests that Apple and Google explicitly went into business in 2005 to provide a default search engine to Apple Computers as a means to control the search industry. As a part of this conspiracy, Apple agreed to not develop a search engine.
Apple’s lack of search engine apparently meant Google was able to control the market and set prices. Since the lawsuit is against Apple, it seems to place the blame for Google’s high ad prices at Apple’s feet.
Flawed logic on all sides
There are many logical flaws with this argument, like Apple’s lack of market share in 2005. The company seemingly had zero interest in developing a search engine at the time and merely needed one for its customers.
Google is the default search engine in Safari
Google was a business offering a search engine, and the deal meant Apple got a share of search ad revenue. The judge seems to ignore all of the evidence and agrees that the plaintiff has a viable complaint.
Even though the partnership was modified to include iPhone in 2007, it wasn’t a major player for years after. Apple didn’t start exceeding 40% market share in most markets until around 2020 in some places.
The partnership with Google was also for a default search engine, not the only search engine. Customers have always had the ability to choose alternatives like Bing.
What’s more, the class action is moving forward in a world where Apple has its own internet ad business. There’s also Apple’s Spotlight and Siri that can be used almost entirely in place of a search engine.
It will be an odd class action to watch as the trial attempts to set the potential damages. The plaintiff suggests that Apple is responsible for the higher prices that Google sets for its ads, thus Apple must pay out to victims.
The whole thing is maddeningly convoluted, as the company that sets the prices and controls the search market isn’t even part of the lawsuit. It is one heck of a head scratcher why any judge would allow this to move forward, but perhaps more will be revealed at trial.
No trial dates have been set.
Source: www.appleinsider.com
Source link
